The verdict is in...
Initially, the book heightens my fear of sequels to this great a book. Sure, i read Batman: Dark Knight Returns, Watchmen, Preacher etc and say "damn i want more!" but i have to respect phenomenal writing and well done endings. In my eye, poor sequels do not diminish their superior predecessors; one can always cover his ears and yell "LALALA IM NOT LISTNEING" and such. Such was my concern for Batman:DKSA.
The book is a hefty eight bucks, but double sized. The lenght is a great shift from the recent Marvel Ultimate books, which while great reads, have somewhere around 20 pages or so an issue, minus all the adds. Yahven's made the point about Kevin Smith's Green Arrow: cliffhangers are interestin, but people are startin to read comics mostly in trade paperback format 'cause the month to month wait for a tidbit (See "Origin") is harsh.
The art hasnt changed a notch since DKR in the eighties. Some will see this as stagnation; i see this as appropriate. Even Frank Miller's superb narraration would be awkward next to, say, Jim Lee or Alex Ross' art.
Good pace, clever foreshadowing, politics and society satire..its all back. Being that this is only issue 1 of 3, im not entirely comfortable reviewin it just yet, but i did so to say this: the potential to do what a sequel to this book should is very much there. The end has you cursing its bimonthly release, but ive never been as excited about some of what i consider to be DC's weaker characters. I'll say more as the series progresses, but you will not be disappointed.